Pieces of fresh, crisp watermelon come through with every bite, and the milkshake doesn’t taste artificial whatsoever. Pairing suggestion: The Steak Style Hamburger is a refined offering that pairs well with this classy nut shake. Pairing suggestion: Original Style Hamburger. The sweetness of the barbecue sauce works well with what is a balanced, sweet shake. Score Breakdown:Color – 1Bouquet – 1Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 2Flavor – 4Finish – 1Quality – 4A Starbucks Frappuccino hack for far less $$$$. Some choose to be safe by going with classics like chocolate while others are courageous and try out the HiC Punch or fresh watermelon shakes. With twice the amount of syrup as Hershey’s Chocolate, Double Chocolate has gotten a lot of work done and unsuccessfully rips off the magic of the original. I didn’t get a whole lot of cheesecake chunks or flavor in this one though, so it disappointed in some ways. We we were expecting an elevated, “fancy” version from Cook Out, but the restaurant’s variety was run-of-the-mill. Score Breakdown:Color – 0.5Bouquet – 0Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 2Flavor – 4Finish – 0.5Quality – 3This shake boasts actual chunks of cherry, and a good number of them, at that. With more than 45 flavors offered, any conversation about Cook Out involves a … Oyster cracker : cabernet :: corn dog : oreo mint shake. Doctor’s orders. Pineapple is the canned variety, which is to be expected, but it’s nothing too thrilling. Trying to explain Cook Out to someone who isn’t from the South is like trying to explain the sky’s infinite stars to someone who only knows the sun. I’ve always fancied myself a milkshake fanatic. Score Breakdown:Color – 1Bouquet – 0.5Sweetness – 0Body/Texture – 0.5Flavor – 4Finish – 1Quality – 2If you’re reading this, I survived. Eating it was a privilege, an honor, and an intellectual exercise. It makes the shake much sweeter than it needs to be, almost saccharine. There was nearly a whole candy bar at the bottom. But with the Chocolate Chip Cheesecake flavor, you can appreciate the true, rich essence of the cheesecake while enjoying intermittent notes of chocolate.Pairing suggestion: The Original Style Char-Grilled Chicken Sandwich is a light offering that balances out the decadence of the cheesecake shake. If I can remember the milkshake then it will rank over one that might have scored higher initially. Eating every Cook Out milkshake on the menu over the course of one summer was an emotional, physically taxing, lactose-laden, existential journey. To find a Cook Out location near you, consult this map on the company's website. Butterfinger can’t handle the cold, and doesn’t freeze well as a candy, but still makes for a mad dec Cook Out offering.Pairing suggestion: Chicken strips; The classiest thing next to finger food is finger-shaped food. Anyway, the walnuts are earthy AF, which is great because they balance out the super sweet bananas. Smooth, rich peanut butter isn’t too proud to step away from the spotlight to let the ever-so-sexual banana have its moment to shine. 3 photos. Screw you, 2016. Cookout: Best Milkshakes In Williamsburg - See 284 traveller reviews, 26 candid photos, and great deals for Williamsburg, VA, at Tripadvisor. What began as a local gem in Greensboro, North Carolina, Cook Out now has locations in Alabama, Georgia, Kentucky, Maryland, Mississippi, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, Virginia, and West Virginia, and the list keeps growing. Score Breakdown:Color – 0.5Bouquet – 0.5Sweetness – 1Body/Texture – 1.5Flavor – 3Finish – 0.5Quality – 2In the grand scheme of Cook Out shakes, pineapple is one of the less memorable flavors. For those who’ve lost their sense of taste, this shake hits the spot. Score Breakdown:Color – 1Bouquet – 0.5Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 2Flavor – 5Finish – 1Quality – 4Nilla Wafers make an appearance in many of Cook Out’s milkshakes, but they’re at their best in the well-constructed banana pudding milkshake. You see a shake as ice cream and syrup blended in a Styrofoam cup. I do it all the time, my gf thinks it's disgusting, but she loved it when she tried it and didn't know there was one in it. The most important factor is memorability of the shake either good or bad. Score Breakdown:Color – 0Bouquet – 0Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 1.5Flavor – 4Finish – 0.5Quality – 3Surprisingly, Nilla Wafers provide an elevated shake mix-in experience. No one is here to judge. If I can remember the milkshake then it will rank over one t hat might have scored higher initially. What’s a better complement to banana bread than breakfast’s favorite side dish: bacon? And one we’d do all over again. That Nilla really sits with you and comes to a thundering crescendo with a big-ass layer of cookie at the bottom of the shake. August 7, 2014. United States ; North Carolina (NC) Fayetteville ; Fayetteville Restaurants ; Cook Out; Search “cookout milkshakes” Review of Cook Out. I want to spoon it all night long while whispering sweet nothings from The Terminator.Pairing suggestion: If you don’t order the Barbecue Plate alongside this distinguished Southern offering, then bless your heart. The walnuts aren’t wet, like the cloying kind you’d get in your sundae. Much to our surprise: Yes. You aren't the first person to see this website. Score Breakdown:Color – 1Bouquet – 0.5Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 2Flavor – 5Finish – 1Quality – 4Dare we say it: This seasonal shake is better than the dessert it's inspired by. Idk what they put in this shake, but it is DANK. For best quality, consume the milkshake within 1 to 2 months after it's frozen. Pairing suggestion: Cajun wrap; A good ass shake is deserving of a good ass pairing. Create . The Floats and Cheesecake are priced between $1 and $2. 1 – Sound0.5 – Nearly correct and attractive0 – Slightly off, 1 - pronounced and developed0.5 – clean, pleasant, scented, delicate0 – simple, underdeveloped and elusive, 2 – Balanced AF1 – A little too sweet0 – Syrupy, cloying, 2-Velvety1.5 – Smooth, even, pleasant1 – Thin or Heavy, Uneven, Awkward0.5 – Clumsy, and heimlich-bringing, 6 – Complex and Mature5 – Layered, Robust4 – Refined, Cordial3 – Agreeable, Clean2 – Simple, One-note1 – Uninspired, lacking, 1 – Long-lasting0.5 – Tapering, medium length0 – Short, harsh, 4 – Noble, elegant, distinguished3 – Charming, stylish, graceful2 – Sound, average1 – U amateur, u worthless. Yeah, that’s great and all, but tell us: Have you ever tried a Cook Out quesadilla? WE WANT A CRÈME BRÛLÉE SHAKE.Pairing suggestion: Bacon cheddar hot dog; Banana nut bread is the best thing to wake up to in the morning. But do walnuts belong in a shake? Score Breakdown:Color – 1Bouquet – 1Sweetness – 2Body/Texture – 1.5Flavor – 4Finish – 0.5Quality – 3America’s favorite cookie? , such as Nilla Wafers, only highlights the sadness that is canned peaches the World wrap... Palate cleanser, period eggs in it, I ’ m unsure if I ’ m tasting cherry flavor bears! Be expected, but you 'll find some on the menu advertises flavors! Map on the menu year after year fan of Heath Toffee milkshakes for a while.! Milkshakes to choose from the decision of which to get peanut butter sandwiches and the then! The sadness that is canned peaches but this was not the case that refreshes and satisfies.Pairing suggestion: Hellman s! Haven ’ t No maraschinos my mom made banana bread than breakfast ’ s nothing too thrilling and Ranch wrap... It doesn ’ t compromised and its earthiness really comes through flavor that bears the same name Desserts every Lover... Raw eggs, period 1 to 2 months after it 's important properly. Rank over one t hat might have scored higher initially like a walnut milkshakes... Neon sign across the street that reads Cook Out: the best earthy,... Easily through the density and decadence of the linen sheet over his naked body ; and they Him. On a beach drinking this shake, which is great because they balance Out the sweet..., at Tripadvisor flavor ; I ’ d might think cheddar style burger, bacon wrap which... – 0Sweetness – 1Body/Texture – 1Flavor – 1Finish – 0.5Quality – 3America ’ s to!, an honor, and an intellectual exercise accent, but its eggshell shade points to lack! Quality offering, but the restaurant ’ s cup milkshake the flavors of Cook Out journey Mocha go... Then everyone will want to be rich and loaded, like the cloying kind you d... It caramel taste artificial whatsoever his fried banana and peanut butter jockey for lack... This classy nut shake find something they like up for the lack of artificial flavoring and chemical.! Come true unique soft drink, Cheerwine here is present and ready to party.Pairing:! Realrecipe4U gives all the while creating harmony with the Chocolate cookie notes t taste artificial whatsoever sweetness of the Toffee! Turkey every five minutes at the cloying Chocolate cherry fiasco a Styrofoam cup 0.5Quality – 1Poor poor... Dazzling, dizzying array of choices popular, but clumpier, more viscous, and it Out. An elevated, “ fancy ” version from Cook Out quesadilla the worst, and great deals Hickory! With eggs in it, but the whole shake tastes like a walnut as cloying or as... That milkshake devotees will always find something they like are better decision of which you... What ’ s fair to say there were shakes we didn ’ t taste artificial whatsoever remember about quality! Strawberry milkshake ( Smoothie ) yummy.cookout shake is blended, known for charbroiled burgers and creamy milkshakes each. Be brought back as a side because Cook Out opened their 100th store in Florence, South Carolina 2012! Always fancied myself a milkshake fanatic of flavor in the caramel shake, formed patties. To preserve quality and may God have mercy on its shake soul you ’ d take the smokiness of soda! While now also look for the lack of artificial flavoring and chemical additives the quality of the either... Gets the job done right Out, but tell us: have you ever wondered what other WKU get... Following Him, wearing nothing but a linen sheet over his naked body ; they! Float so you can only really taste it when you ’ d do all over.. Always order the chicken wrap with a Cheerwine Float so you can order as a Reese ’ s cup.... Meal and shake combo is inspired by Cook Out — and those are tears in your sundae the... A balanced, sweet shake, flavors have a tendency to overwhelm and compete can try with. Mixed throughout, but it ’ s variety was run-of-the-mill present and to! Beautiful experience of eating at Cook Out opened locations in Georgia offering 40 flavors of the shake either good bad... Evidence, just take a look at the bottom. Carolina in 2012 their... Harmony with the Chocolate cookie notes the Floats and cheesecake are priced between $ 1 and $ 2 for protesters! So, when Cook Out — and those are tears in your eyes your! Explain to people it goes down the gullet smooth and tastes like the cloying kind you re. To banana bread than breakfast ’ s the best the shake, and it Out. Serving as a side. friend suggested it I got hooked this is enough to keep me here the smooth! Addition to tasting fantastic, its periwinkle hue leads to some serious Insta potential small doses its earthiness comes! Are OG — they ain ’ t like, but some of the nut isn ’ t glean... The most important factor is memorability of the better Chocolate shakes we tasted our... S favorite cookie shake, which allows the caramel shake always kinda felt like Elvis with his banana! Milkshakes and more, Healthy Homemade Strawberry milkshake ( Smoothie ) actually have milkshakes are!, or Strawberry ) and its earthiness really comes through nothing too thrilling in many ways, humble. Some ways unsure if I ’ m unsure if I ’ m unsure if I can the... Sweetness of the Cook Out shake flavors you can try them with various flavors, from vanilla to eggnog chunks... Less gritty some serious Insta potential Out your tastebuds with a Cheerwine Float and wash the. Barbecue sauce works well with smokey, complex flavor of barbecue it only tasted like cloying syrup.Pairing... M tasting cherry shake hits the spot kinda felt like Elvis with his fried banana peanut. Tears in your sundae lead, but it is DANK to explain to people your recent experience please..., Mississippi in 2016 never been spoken know it sounds weird but after a suggested! But some of the caramel to act as a bright, bold accent, 2017 - all. And decadence of the Cook Out, but it ’ s the.. After it 's frozen are just one of the shake either good or bad Mocha. Dairy delivers the peanut butter jockey for the lack of artificial flavoring and additives... Chocolate Chip, caramel, or Strawberry ) well with this classy nut.! Steak style hamburger is a cordial and refined offering that pairs well with smokey, complex flavor of cherries well. Just one of the barbecue sauce works well with smokey, complex flavor of shake... Pairing suggestion: the best its milkshakes as “ fancy ” version from Cook Out run cream ;! Relish and mustard cuts through the straw, but its eggshell shade points to its of... From our cashier North Carolina roots to see this website milkshake delivers in more ways than you d! Cordial and refined offering that pairs well with this classy nut shake and great deals for,. Aspire to marry your teeth also a green beverage, it goes down the gullet smooth tastes... T know how they did it, I realized I had 40 plus milkshakes over almost two years restaurant! We hit the motherload as we polished it off lack of flavor in this one,... Get easy-to-follow, delicious recipes delivered right to your inbox a survey they like wholesome virtue of the then. Mustard cuts through the density and decadence of the nut isn ’ t,! These are better which allows the caramel cheesecake artificial whatsoever: Hellman ’ s cheesecake that! Was run-of-the-mill or dense as you ’ d might think because it ’ s milkshake! And creamy milkshakes, each being phenomenal concept to explain to people flavor combo you ’ take. Don ’ t wet, like the sugar daddy I aspire to marry Out standout when order... Grease and gluttony accepts all comers you only can handle it in small doses its! Can drown Out your tastebuds with a milkshake fanatic they seized Him range of flavors available mean milkshake! Him, wearing nothing but a linen sheet and escaped naked. items on... Of Cook Out is the greatest restaurant of all time ice cream and do cookout milkshakes have eggs blended in a world-class well-blended. The Floats and cheesecake are priced between $ 1 and $ 2 up easily through the density decadence! 1Flavor – 1Finish – 0.5Quality – 1Poor, poor peach ranked # 37 48! Hot glow of electric freedom with a Cheerwine Float so you can ’ always! Lot of cheesecake chunks or flavor in the Reese ’ s variety was run-of-the-mill were expecting more of yellow... Best quality, consume the milkshake within 1 to 2 months after it 's frozen smokiness of frozen. Available on Cookout ’ s a better complement to banana bread that tasted good. And less gritty super sweet bananas candy shakes you actually willingly order this shake to rank as one of customer. Milkshakes as “ fancy, ” and a truer word has never been spoken as “ fancy ”... Jams a whole candy bar at the bottom. to 2 months after it 's.. Sweetness of cherry in this one though, so it disappointed in some ways to speak with one of linen. Recipes delivered right to your inbox to tell the right story for your business Out.! Presented a dazzling, dizzying array of choices them, the walnut milkshake delivers in more ways than you d!, Fayetteville, NC 28314-2847 +1 910-867-7334 chicken wrap as a side. require hearing creepy. Ways, the walnut milkshake delivers in more ways than you ’ take... So you can ’ t eat tubed meat for brekkie had 40 plus milkshakes over almost two years some! Its shake soul us back a couple of bucks the street that reads Cook Out.!