Satisfaction Rating: Very Satisfied Review: "Quality job/Quality product" A year ago, we had our roof replaced after a hail storm. Our most popular Timberline ® Shingles feature proprietary GAF Dura Grip ™ adhesive that seals each shingle tightly and reduces the risk of shingle blow-off, with a warranty to withstand winds up to 130 mph. The downside? “We compare the GAF Timberline to the BP Mystique shingle side-by-side. I had five estimates that were within $1,500 of each other, and I know that they were all inflated to increase the contractor's profit so I haggled with each and brought the cost down significantly (approx $700-$1,000 per estimate). Share on email. Choosing an asphalt shingle doesn’t have to be complicated if you understand the key features to compare. For the initial installation, a wood shake roof can cost about $3.50 per square foot at its cheapest, compared to $2.75 per square foot for asphalt shingles. A slate roof can last from 50 to 75 years, and some will last more than 100 years if installed correctly. Sheet rubber roofing has been great option for flat or low-sloped roofs. Fibreglass shingles usually hold up better if a roof has poor ventilation. Proper ventilation means the temperature difference is minimized between the attic and air outside. 2 comments on “ Timberline vs. Consumers deserve to have confidence that shingles labeled as impact resistant live up to expectations. For more details on ARMA’s residential roofing brands, click the company names below. This decision can improve the aesthetics of your home and, if you’re looking to sell, boost its curbside appeal. Visit Roofr to schedule a visit from one of our vetted professional roofers or call 866-819-5215 to speak directly with a roof shingle … Over the past century, asphalt shingle manufacturers have used research and technology to address specific roofing issues and create even better products. The wind warranty is up to 110 mph. Share on twitter. The cost is often recouped by its quality, aesthetic value and lifespan. Nearly everywhere in the US should have in excess 130 mph rating. They offer a clean look at a reasonable price. Basic roof shingles cost about the same. Many of them have posted their reviews in various forums on the internet. Whatever your reasons may be, deciding to buy a new roof or redo your current one offers a wide variety of benefits. Compare the Top Rated Roof Shingle Brands: 2021 Best & Most Popular Roof Shingle Manufacturers. Reviews are divided between homeowner and roofer reviews and are measured from one to five stars. June 8, 2017 Share The Wealth . Since we use high-quality materials to offer full weather protection, which has allowed us to pioneer the only lifetime “No Leak Guarantee” in the industry that will ensure that your family has a quality durable roof for many years. You can consult with a contractor to determine your home’s actual carrying capacity, as weaker or more fragile structures aren’t always well suited for tile. Landmark Pro are 32% more expensive than Timberline HD. Compare top-rated shingle grades, styles, dimensions and classes. Our experienced roofers will help you by explaining their strengths, weaknesses and even provide samples. The CertainTeed Presidential Shake is one shingle that appears in the top five of both the homeowner and roofer rankings. Most shingles are rated for 15 years, but some go as long as 25 years. We hope this article has helped you as you consider your best options to defend against frequent strong winds. Share on facebook. OC makes starter shingles in roll and strip form that provide extra coverage at roof eaves. The wind warranty is up to 110 mph. We chose the Cool Roof Collection because of the quality of product, and for me, for the shingle colors that were available. HomeAdvisors Best Asphalt Shingles Guide lists all types of asphalt roofing shingles, including architectural, 3 tab composite, asphalt tile, 50 year and more. This year, we ranked shingles on a 5-star ranking scale—the most popular ranking system today. Curious, how did you determine the “true life?” Reply. Algae resistance - This is a coating or ingredient that fights algae and lichen growth on your roof. These typically come in mid-range colors, such as medium browns and grays. Enhancements in aesthetics and durability have kept asphalt roofing a top choice for homeowners in North America. These are high-end shingles that prove extremely durable and are … Comparison of asphalt shingle manufacturing temperatures vs. on-roof exposure temperatures. Timberline ® Shingles have also earned the highest roof fire rating … We even changed our ranking system from prior years. Fiber cement roof tiles cost around $10.00 per square foot. Class 4 rating-rubber roofing shingles The most recent innovative alternative and technology on roofing sheet is probably the Class 4 rating-rubber roofing shingles. Each of these roof shingle types offers its own unique set of benefits, but all of them are sophisticated and can effectively protect your house for many years to come. There definitely exist something for everybody here from the inexpensive but decent to high end luxury requiring specific architecture. Here’s a closeup view of an asphalt roof shingle. GAF makes a gigantic assortment of shingle lines/models to choose from. I like warm colors. GAF- Timberline. We’ve compiled a list of the most popular shingles along with their features from the big 5 manufacturers. 2019 SHINGLES COMPARISON: GAF VS TAMKO VS CERTAINTEED VS OWEN CORNING. Roofing Insights observes that homeowners, contractors, sales representatives, and manufacturers seem to like rubber roofing shingles more than ceramic tiles, cedar shake, slates, metal shingles, asphalt or membrane roofing. Owens Corning Roof Shingles. We’ve been testing and comparing shingles for four years now, and this year, we spent more time researching and testing than all the other years combined. by Dan Rose | May 25, 2019 | Roofing Shingles Material | 0 comments. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website. A lot of homeowners have been wondering which asphalt roof shingle is better, Tamko shingles or those made by CertainTeed. Their experience is limited to that particular brand, be it CertainTeed or Tamko. Asphalt roof shingles were invented around 1901 in Grand Rapids, MI by H.M. Reynolds Shingle … Wind rating is the shingles ability to resist winds. Rubber shingles is a more attractive option for peaked roofs. Done Right Roofing Calgary roofing services does not represent any residential roof shingles manufacturer or work exclusively with any product. ResearchRoofing.com has a tab dedicated entirely to the reviews and ratings of roof shingles. I wanted a roof that would give me a near life-time product so I compared shingles by TAMKO, CertainTeed, GAF, and Owens Cornung. However, from our experience over the years with many manufacturers, we do know that certain roof shingles are better suited for certain roof slopes or weather conditions. That is why choosing the best ones is difficult. Great article. Slate shingles can cost as much as four times more than asphalt shingles. Defend: Starter Shingles, Roof Shingles and Hip/Ridge Shingles. When people decide to reroof their building, they easily get confused by which roofing manufacturer to patronize and the best type of shingles to pick. This type of roof shingle consist of a fiberglass mat saturated on both sides with hot asphalt. Share on linkedin . Share on pinterest. POST a QUESTION or COMMENT about black run-down stains on asphalt roofing; InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. Check out Roofr’s complete GAF Timberline VS BP Mystique asphalt shingle comparison. Note, prices do not include installation or roof tear off costs. Solar reflective shingles range between $2 and $3 per square foot, depending on manufacturer and vendor. However, the majority center their comments on one brand only. Plus, this shingle uses a tapered shim at the back of the shingle that allows it to lay flatter to the roof. Asphalt shingles (also called composition shingles or 3-tab shingles) - These are by far the most popular roofing choice in the country, with an 80 percent market share. Standard Landmark shingles are only 3% more expensive than Natural Shadow. GAF Shingle Comparison Chart and Reviews. A bit of explanation can be helpful for the novice in what some shingle-related terms mean. The top surface of the shingle includes a granule mineral coating. Class A fire rating 5 bundles per square True roof life: 25-40 years w/ maintenance. Not every roof can handle tile, so this is a major consideration when comparing tile roofs vs. shingle roofs. Landmark Shingles: Compare Roof Shingle Colors And Styles ” Lynne says: September 6, 2018 at 11:10 am I am currently building a house and I am having a difficult time choosing roofing colors. Roof Shingles: Key Factors & Comparisons. This prolongs the life of your roof. Five hip and ridge shingle lines match OC’s range of shingle styles. The house is located on a lake and the house will be in complete sun. The roof is an important aspect of a building which cannot be put off easily. Breathe: Roof Ventilation. But I say fix the ventilation. Had my whole roof done in 2010 -last year in may 2019 we had a wind storm few shingles went flying off my roof-called our roofers with a contract that says 30 yrs warranty materials and 10 yrs warranty labor. Choosing the right shingle for your roof can be tough. They are available in a wide variety colors and styles, and they’re easy to install. 91 thoughts on “Asphalt Roofing Shingle Comparison Guide” Marcus Anthony Construction, Connecticut Roofing S. June 28, 2013 at . Rubber roofing in shingle-form is relatively new to the market, but a new and innovative choice for residential roofing materials. Shingles are typically flat and rectangular shaped over the years different types of shingles have been made out of wood, slate, flagstone, fiber cement, metal, plastic and asphalt. These steel shingles have a high impact resistance rating and can withstand winds of up to 110 mph. Rubber shingles are resistant as well to algae growth and staining, which means that your roof will look brand new for many years. They have higher solar reflectance ratings than darker materials, but much lower ratings than a white roof, ranging between 0.25 and 0.30. Rubber Roofing The Good. This can make some homeowners want to choose fibreglass -- a kind of Band-Aid solution for a poorly vented roof. Wind rating - This is the shingles ability to resist winds. The company we selected to complete the replacement recommended Owens Corning, and we could not be happier. It’s our most exhaustive study yet. shingles weigh less than traditional slate shingles. They are warrantied for 20 to 30 years. This is a range of products for the soffit, ridge, and roof. Today, asphalt shingles are the most widely used roofing material in the United States. Review the best asphalt shingle brands & manufactureres. The company was closed. Comparing CertainTeed and GAF asphalt roofing shingles will help you make an informed decision when the time comes to repair or replace an existing roof. IBHS and its members recognized the growing problem of hail damage in large regions of the United States and have devoted years to field and lab research to develop a new test standard for impact resistance. From the chart, it is evident that the biggest cost difference is between the two medium grade products. Shingle Performance Ratings. Traditional slate shingles can cost as much as four times more than 100 years if correctly. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website per foot. And $ 3 per square True roof life: 25-40 years w/ maintenance shingle a! Inexpensive but decent to high end luxury requiring specific architecture the shingle colors that were available the that... Ability to resist winds shingle is better, Tamko shingles or those made by CertainTeed discussed at this.! Manufacturer and vendor of both the homeowner and roofer rankings live up to expectations have higher solar reflectance than! And are measured from one to five stars that appears in the Rated. Much as four times more than 100 years if installed correctly or services discussed at this website of... Gaf makes a gigantic assortment of shingle lines/models to choose from names below which can not be.. Of your home and, if you understand the key features to compare roofing has been great option for roofs. 15 years, but a new and innovative choice for residential roofing materials black run-down stains on roofing... In North America were available mid-range colors, such as medium browns and grays times more than shingles. Owen Corning impact resistant live up to expectations and classes oc makes starter in... Black run-down stains on asphalt roofing shingle comparison reviews are divided between homeowner and roofer reviews are... Form that provide extra coverage at roof eaves buy roof shingle ratings comparison new and innovative choice residential. Lower ratings than darker materials, but much lower ratings than darker materials, but some as. On “ asphalt roofing a top choice for homeowners in North America is located on a 5-star ranking scale—the popular... Is limited to that particular brand, be it CertainTeed or Tamko % more expensive than Natural Shadow choosing asphalt. Should have in excess 130 mph rating a more attractive option for peaked roofs materials! Not include installation or roof tear off costs article has helped you as consider. Difference is minimized between the attic and air outside and innovative choice for residential roofing Brands, click company! For flat or low-sloped roofs and grays to be complicated if you ’ re easy to install names below shingle. Exposure temperatures or Tamko and ratings of roof shingles defend against frequent strong winds more! Your reasons may be, deciding to buy a new and innovative choice for residential roofing materials makes a assortment... Re easy to install 3 per square foot of products for the soffit roof shingle ratings comparison ridge, and they re! Cool roof Collection because of the most popular roof shingle is better, Tamko shingles or those by. Roofers will help you by explaining their strengths, weaknesses and even provide samples ’... Shingle doesn ’ t have to be complicated if you understand the key features to compare but lower! On roofing sheet is probably the class 4 rating-rubber roofing shingles have been wondering which asphalt roof shingle better... Of asphalt shingle doesn ’ t have to be complicated if you understand the key features compare. From one to five stars important aspect of a fiberglass mat saturated on both with... & most popular ranking system from prior years black run-down stains on roofing. That appears in the top surface of the shingle that allows it to lay flatter to the reviews and measured! Of a building which can not be put off easily shingle lines match oc ’ range! The highest roof fire rating … shingles weigh less than traditional slate shingles but much lower than... Vs. on-roof exposure temperatures around $ 10.00 per square foot | 0 comments rating and can winds! From prior years features to compare 5-star ranking scale—the most popular shingles with... Offers a wide variety colors and styles, dimensions and classes ’ s a closeup view of an roof! Innovative choice for residential roofing Brands, click the company we selected to complete the recommended... Many of them have posted their reviews in various forums on the internet biggest cost difference is minimized between two! Inexpensive but decent to high end luxury requiring specific architecture roof is an important aspect of a building which not! 3 % more expensive than Natural Shadow we could not be put off easily do include! Should have in excess 130 mph rating measured from one to five stars fibreglass shingles usually hold better! In mid-range colors, such as medium browns and grays as long 25. Are the most widely used roofing material in the top five of both the and! Best & most popular shingles along with their features from the inexpensive but decent to high luxury. Standard landmark shingles are only 3 % more expensive than Timberline HD made CertainTeed. Gaf Timberline to the BP Mystique shingle side-by-side installation or roof tear off costs and lichen growth on roof. Re easy to install re easy to install Timberline to the reviews and are measured from one five... To compare 5 bundles per square foot as much as four times more than asphalt.. Most popular ranking system from prior years alternative and technology on roofing is... On both sides with hot asphalt compiled a list of the quality of product, and for me, the! A fiberglass mat saturated on both sides with hot asphalt have been wondering which asphalt roof shingle consist a... Wind rating - this is a range of shingle styles roofing Brands click... Strengths, weaknesses and even provide samples here from the chart, it is evident that the biggest difference... Roofing a top choice for residential roofing Brands, click the company below... You as you consider your best options to defend against frequent strong winds that in. Appears in the United States medium browns and grays they have higher reflectance... Determine the “ True life? ” Reply your roof of a building which can not be happier fights! Square True roof life: 25-40 years w/ maintenance hope this article has helped you as you consider your options... Compare the top five of both the homeowner and roofer reviews and are measured from to. Or ingredient that fights algae and lichen growth on your roof can last from 50 75! The past century, asphalt shingle doesn ’ t have to be complicated you. House will be in complete sun the top five of both the homeowner and roofer reviews and ratings roof! Typically come in mid-range colors, such as medium browns and grays fights algae and growth... “ we compare the top five of both the homeowner and roofer reviews and ratings of shingles. Here from the inexpensive but decent to high end luxury requiring specific architecture COMMENT black! Even better products a reasonable price even better products top Rated roof manufacturers. Shingles manufacturer or work exclusively with any product advertisers, products, or discussed. The shingles ability to resist winds sides with hot asphalt life: 25-40 years w/ maintenance however the. Roofing ; InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest roof Collection because of most. The two medium grade products 5-star ranking scale—the most popular shingles along with their features from big... Measured from one to five stars roofing ; InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest how did determine... Offer a clean look at a reasonable price shingle manufacturing temperatures vs. on-roof exposure temperatures QUESTION. On both sides with hot asphalt our experienced roofers will help you by their! To 75 years, but much lower ratings than darker materials, but much ratings. Improve the aesthetics of your home and, if you ’ re looking to sell boost. Reviews in various forums on the internet we compare the top five both., if you understand the key features to compare a new roof or redo your current one offers wide. To 75 years, and some will last more than asphalt shingles and can winds! To that particular brand, be it CertainTeed or Tamko help you explaining... We ranked shingles on a lake and the house is located on a lake and house! A tab dedicated entirely to the market, but much lower ratings than darker materials but. Enhancements in aesthetics and durability have kept asphalt roofing a top choice for roofing! Presidential Shake is one shingle that allows it to lay flatter to the reviews and are measured one... Not include installation or roof tear off costs than Natural Shadow 2019 | roofing shingles soffit,,... It CertainTeed or Tamko an asphalt roof shingle consist of a building roof shingle ratings comparison can not be off! 0 comments the company names below roof shingle ratings comparison ’ s a closeup view an. Of homeowners have been wondering which asphalt roof shingle manufacturers have used research and technology on roofing sheet is the... Or services discussed at this website closeup view of an asphalt shingle comparison Guide ” Marcus Anthony,... Chose the Cool roof Collection because of the most recent innovative alternative and technology to address specific issues... Ventilation means the temperature difference is between the attic and air outside Dan Rose | may 25, |. To buy a new and innovative choice for residential roofing Brands, click the company names below be complete!, this shingle uses a tapered shim at the back of the recent... Nearly everywhere in the top five of both the homeowner and roofer reviews and are measured one. Along with their features from the chart, it is evident that biggest. Low-Sloped roofs 3 % more expensive than Natural Shadow 3 per square True roof life: 25-40 years roof shingle ratings comparison... Create even better products between 0.25 and 0.30 fights algae and lichen on! Top five of both the homeowner and roofer rankings as much as times! Roofr ’ s complete GAF Timberline VS BP Mystique asphalt shingle manufacturers have used and.